This is from Thingiverse:8100. ( http://www.thingiverse.com/thing:8100 ) I first tried with no support.

This is from Thingiverse:8100. (http://www.thingiverse.com/thing:8100) I first tried with no support. The propeller/antenna thingy came off as a short stub. (Left) I thought support would help, so I added the usual support style in KISSlicer. G-Code viewer shows some support structure below that thingy, so I went print. But the stem broke at about the same length despite surrounding support. (Looking at the dimensions, I also worry about support removal in this structure.)

I looked up Thingiverse. One maker posted a picture of this thing standing on print bed as one piece (https://cdn.thingiverse.com/renders/8d/fb/13/64/52/G0011830_preview_featured.JPG), apparently with no support. This means that the model is printable. What could have gone wrong?

What’s your layer height? Perhaps it’s too thin of a surface to print at your current settings.

Ah quite. I use 0.2mm.

Umm, how big are you printing that? It’s hard to get a sense of scale, but the Make on the Di3 looks much larger than yours. That makes a big difference with small details. The cross-section of the dish support is too small in your print.

That doesn’t look like it’s designed for a small print if part of it was too thin then the slicer most likely ignored it altogether and thus giving you a super weak structure

Here is a possibility:

In Slic3r there is a setting called “Slow Down if Layer Print Time is Below X seconds”, under Filament Settings -> Cooling thresholds.

Depending on the temperature you are printing you may need the cooling fan full-on with this setting to allow enough cooling of the plastic of the previous layer before putting more plastic on top.

If the plastic is still too hot when the next layer is laid down it tends to clump together into a blobby mess.

I assume that Kissilcer has an equivalent setting.

I needed this setting when I wanted to print Warhammer 40,000 figures using PLA, to get the fine details right.

@Ryan_Carlyle , @Griffin_Paquette Good pointer! The lurch guy also posted a metered photo https://cdn.thingiverse.com/renders/f6/7e/fc/1e/6e/3077cedc7ecd99002420e7196beff956_preview_featured.jpg. That’s roughly twice as big as mine. Do you just scale STL for a larger print? I always thought I’d just download and slice as is.

@Paul_Gross I’ll look into KISSlicer for the feature. Perhaps I could also tweak print temperature. I haven’t done any optimization. As slicing goes, G-code viewer does show that disc structure in perhaps 3 or 4 layers.

There should a a scale feature build right into the slicer. I know there is in Cura, Slic3r, and Simplify 3D

If I were you, I would cut off the disk and print it separately. I printed this before and got better results that way.

@Samer_Najia That was what I suspected when I first saw the result. Only this lurch’s one-piece pictures make me curious